Comparing cloud access and video security: Avigilon vs. Verkada

In today’s rapidly evolving landscape of physical security, selecting the right access control and video security provider is more crucial than ever. Two significant players in the space are Verkada and Avigilon, each offering cloud-native solutions that provide simplicity, scalability and security. While they share similarities, there are considerable differences in each brand’s approach to hardware design, system integrations, user experience and scalability.

This comprehensive guide compares Avigilon vs. Verkada, helping you evaluate which solution best fits your organization’s security needs.

Verkada overview

Since Verkada was founded in 2016, the company has grown rapidly in the physical security space by offering integrated systems that are easy to deploy and manage. Their security products are built to work with Command, their centralized, cloud-managed software, which connects video security, access control and visitor management into one platform.

Key offerings:

• Access control: Readers and door controllers with a dedicated controller board
• Video security: Hybrid cloud cameras with features like license plate recognition and motion detection 
• Verkada Guest: A visitor management app that offers digital check-in and integrates with Verkada’s video and access control systems
• Command platform: A centralized interface to manage access, view video footage, launch lockdowns and check systems

Verkada focuses on ease of deployment and a closed ecosystem that allows all hardware and software to work together seamlessly. However, this approach may limit flexibility for businesses that rely on third-party systems or plan to scale.

Avigilon overview

Avigilon offers a cloud-native physical security platform, Avigilon Alta, designed for enterprise environments. Built with open architecture, Avigilon Alta delivers cloud access control, video security, visitor management and intercom functionality in one connected, scalable system.

Key offerings:

• Avigilon Alta access control: Hardware is modular, including readers and controllers, which ensures high uptime and offline operation
• Avigilon Alta video security: ONVIF-compliant platform that supports third-party cameras and AI analytics
• Alta Visitor: Built-in visitor management offering touchless guest check-in, host alerts, time-limited visitor access credentials and paid guest access
• Patented Triple Unlock technology:Enhances the reliability and speed of access by using Bluetooth, Wi-Fi and cellular data 
• Open API and integration library: Extensive integrations with 100+ platforms, including identity provider, tenant and communication tools

Avigilon Alta is designed to integrate. The system supports multi-site deployments, making it ideal for many different sectors, including commercial spaces, enterprise campuses and office environments.

Verkada vs. Avigilon: a side-by-side comparison

Mobile credentials and touchless access

Mobile access has become commonplace in physical security, replacing physical credentials like key cards and fobs with smartphone-based credentials.

Both Verkada and Avigilon Alta offer mobile access. Verkada offers mobile credentials through its app, allowing users to unlock doors via Bluetooth-enabled devices. It provides a straightforward touchless experience for organizations looking to streamline access without a complex setup. 

Avigilon Alta’s Wave to Unlock feature uses motion detection and confirms intent, reducing accidental unlocks. Alta’s patented Triple Unlock technology also ensures quick, secure entry with Wi-Fi, Bluetooth and cellular connection, so users can gain access even when one connection type is down.

Avigilon supports iOS, Apple Watch, Android and tablet apps, as well as legacy key cards and fobs to provide flexibility. For organizations looking to upgrade from older systems, Avigilon’s backward-compatible access readers make transitions easier and more cost-effective.

Integration capabilities

Both Verkada and Avigilon Alta offer integration options that enhance the functionality of their platforms. 

Like Verkada’s Command Connector that allows select third-party cameras to be integrated directly into their video management system, Avigilon’s Cloud Connector enables users to apply smart analytics to all their cameras in a single platform.

Beyond camera integrations, Avigilon Alta supports a wider range of integrations with a broader range of technologies, such as:

• Identity management tools 
• Communication platforms
• Property and tenant apps
• Alarm systems 

With over 100 pre-built integrations and an open API, Avigilon Alta offers organizations the flexibility to tailor their physical security ecosystem and seamlessly connect with existing commercial security systems.

Hardware flexibility

When it comes to hardware, both Verkada and Avigilon Alta offer reliable options tailored to the unique security needs of different organizations.

Verkada offers door controllers and readers designed for straightforward deployment, well-suited for small to medium-sized installations. The hardware seamlessly integrates with the Command platform.

Avigilon Alta provides a wider range of hardware, including the Smart Standard, Keypad, Intercom, Video Intercom and USB readers, as well as Smart Hubs and scalable door controllers that support from 1 to 16 doors with additional sensor inputs, relays and backup power options. This variety makes it easier to build systems across various building types and sizes.

Avigilon’s hardware features a modular design that can easily adapt to various commercial environments. Its flexibility makes it ideal for organizations planning larger or more complex installations. 

Visitor access and management

Both Verkada and Avigilon Alta offer digital visitor management solutions designed to improve building security and improve guest access.

Verkada Guest is a visitor management application that requires a separate subscription. It integrates with Verkada’s Command platform to provide features such as touchless check-in, visitor tracking, host notifications and access control integration.

Similar to Verkada Guest, Avigilon Alta’s visitor management system, Alta Visitor, is available with a subscription and works with third-party tools. It provides secure, touchless visitor check-in, real-time host notifications and temporary access through customizable Guest Pass credentials. Alta Visitor also enables organizations to collect payment for temporary access, such as for guest parking, coworking spaces and fitness centers.

For unregistered visitors, such as couriers or unscheduled guests, Avigilon’s Video Intercom Reader Pro allows real-time video and audio communication at access points, with a high-definition built-in camera and clear intercom. The hardware enables operators and occupants to remotely verify identities and grant entries on the spot, boosting convenience while strengthening security. 

When comparing visitor management systems for Verkada vs. Avigilon, organizations should consider subscription requirements and how each system aligns with their existing workflows and security infrastructure.

Safety and emergency features

Avigilon and Verkada both offer remote lockdown capabilities to enable administrators to quickly secure buildings during emergencies.

With Verkada, admins can trigger lockdowns across entry points through the Command dashboard. 

Avigilon Alta offers a lockdown security solution with more granularity. Admins can set customized security scenarios, set door schedules, view activity in real-time and notify first responders instantly. These features are particularly beneficial for schools, hospitals and high-security environments.

Avigilon’s advanced lockdown tools are available at no additional cost to schools and nonprofit organizations, supporting the company’s commitment to public safety.

Cost considerations and scalability

When it comes to costs, Verkada uses a device-based subscription model. This pricing structure can be particularly beneficial for smaller installations, as it enables operators to more accurately predict costs. However, organizations looking to scale may want to consider the total cost of ownership (TCO) over time. When more doors and devices are added, costs can escalate due to per-device licensing, software subscriptions and support services.

It’s also important to note that Verkada hardware may lose functionality if the software subscription is not renewed, which may affect operational continuity and increase costs. 

Avigilon Alta offers flexibility in terms of cost and scalability. Designed for enterprise and commercial deployments, the system can scale from a single door to hundreds of access points. Its open integration model also offers more versatility in how organizations expand to multiple sites and deploy systems across sites.

Additionally, features such as Guest Pass and advanced analytics are available without additional subscriptions. This can help organizations reduce costs while maintaining access to essential security features.

Benefits of Avigilon Alta

Considering Verkada vs. Avigilon for your next security upgrade? Here are a few reasons organizations choose Avigilon Alta:

• Cloud-native and built to scale, with hardware that works offline and integrates with existing systems.
• Multi-function, versatile devices that combine access and video.
• Secure, touchless mobile access with Wave to Unlock and Triple Unlock technology.
• A broad range of robust integrations with other security, business and IT tools.
• Efficient lockdown tools that are available free to eligible nonprofits and schools.

Avigilon vs. Verkada: which solution is right for you?

In the debate between Avigilon vs. Verkada, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Both offer innovative solutions with cloud-based architectures and modern user experiences.

Verkada may be the right fit for mid-sized or smaller businesses looking for simplicity within a closed ecosystem. However, if you’re seeking a security system that is flexible and built for long-term growth, Avigilon Alta might better fit your security and business needs. 

Avigilon Alta also offers convenience with seamless integrations, touchless entry and scalability, as well as enhanced protection with emergency readiness features. The system is designed to help your organization adapt and grow while maintaining robust security.